No Mr President: Questioning the Lamu refinery is not extortion

President William Ruto and Dangote Group President Aliko Dangote. PHOTO/PSCU.

By PATRICK MAYOYO

newsdesk@africaeconews.co.ke

No, Mr President. Kenyans asking questions about the proposed Dangote East Africa Refinery in Lamu are not extortionists. They are citizens and taxpayers exercising their legitimate right to demand accountability from their government.

They are members of communities whose land, livelihoods, environment and cultural heritage could be affected by one of the largest industrial projects ever proposed in Kenya. They are people with legitimate concerns about their future, the future of their children and the preservation of the natural resources upon which their communities depend. They have every right to ask questions, demand answers and insist that the law is respected.

President William Ruto’s decision to dismiss critics of the Sh2.2 trillion Dangote East Africa Refinery as “extortionists” and “brokers” is, in my view, a dangerous attempt to divert public attention from a far more fundamental issue: were all the necessary legal, constitutional and environmental safeguards observed before the country celebrated the project’s groundbreaking?

The real issue is not whether Kenyans should welcome investment. It is whether investment should be pursued at the expense of accountability, environmental protection, public participation and the rights of affected communities. No investor, however wealthy or influential, should be above the law, and no government should expect citizens to surrender their constitutional rights simply because a project is presented as an economic milestone.

Asking questions is not extortion. Demanding transparency is not economic sabotage. And defending one’s land, livelihood, environment and constitutional rights is not hostility towards development. It is responsible citizenship

That question cannot be shouted down. It cannot be dismissed as blackmail. And it certainly cannot be answered by a groundbreaking ceremony.

The refinery was officially launched in Lamu today, with President Ruto and Dangote Group President Aliko Dangote presiding over the ceremony. The proposed refinery is expected to process about 700,000 barrels of crude oil a day and represents a roughly $16 billion investment.

I have no quarrel with investment. I have no quarrel with jobs. I have no quarrel with industrialisation. What I object to is the idea that the bigger the investment, the less scrutiny it should receive.

Big money does not suspend the Constitution. A billionaire’s investment does not outrank Kenyan law. And a presidential groundbreaking ceremony does not retrospectively cure a failure to follow due process.

The starting point is the Environmental Management and Co-ordination Act, 1999.

Section 58(1) requires a project proponent, before financing or commencing an undertaking specified in the Second Schedule, to submit a project report to the National Environment Management Authority (NEMA).

Where NEMA determines that the project may have, or is likely to have, a significant impact on the environment, Section 58(2) requires the proponent to undertake an environmental impact assessment study and prepare a report.  That is not a bureaucratic suggestion. It is the law.

Equipment at the ground-breaking ceremony. PHOTO/PSCU.

And NEMA itself could not be clearer: an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is a legal requirement before commencement of a project, the process requires the proponent to seek the views of people who may be affected, and an EIA licence is to be issued before commencement.

NEMA further states that a proponent or investor should not implement a project for which an EIA is required unless the EIA has been concluded and approved in accordance with the law.

So my question is simple: Where is the environmental assessment? Where is the licence? Where are the documents? Where is the evidence that the public was meaningfully consulted? These are not unreasonable questions. They are precisely the questions the law requires Kenyans to ask.

And for a refinery of this magnitude, the questions become even more important because an environmental assessment is not merely about trees and soil.

NEMA identifies social and human considerations including economic impacts, social disruption, human health, biodiversity and ecosystem protection among matters that should be considered in an EIA.

That is why I would rather talk about the environmental and social consequences that must be assessed through the applicable EIA or Environmental and Social Impact Assessment (ESIA) framework than pretend that a project of this scale can be reduced to a question of investment figures and jobs.

The Constitution is equally clear. Article 10 makes “participation of the people” a national value and principle of governance and binds State organs, State officers, public officers and all persons whenever they apply or interpret the Constitution, enact or apply law, or make or implement public policy decisions.

This is not a decorative phrase inserted into the Constitution to make government documents look democratic. It is a constitutional obligation.

And Article 35 gives every citizen the right of access to information held by the State. It also requires the State to publish and publicise important information affecting the nation.

Your decisions also appear to run contrary to internationally accepted principles of sustainable development, including those articulated in the United Nations 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, the 1987 Brundtland Report and the principles of effective governance for sustainable development endorsed by the United Nations Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC) in 2018.

These are not abstract international declarations that governments invoke when convenient and disregard when pursuing politically attractive investments. They represent an established global understanding of what responsible development should look like, particularly where large-scale industrial projects have the potential to transform communities, economies and fragile ecosystems.

Mr President, the central question is not whether Kenya needs investment, industrialisation, employment opportunities and economic growth. It does. The question is whether these objectives can be pursued at the expense of environmental protection, social justice, public participation and the rights of future generations. Internationally accepted sustainable development principles make it abundantly clear that economic development cannot be separated from its environmental and social consequences.

A project cannot be considered sustainable simply because it promises billions of shillings in investment, thousands of jobs or increased government revenue. Its overall value must also be measured against the social and environmental costs it imposes, the communities it affects and the long-term consequences it creates.

The 1987 Brundtland Report, formally known as Our Common Future, established one of the most widely recognised definitions of sustainable development. It describes sustainable development as development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.

This definition fundamentally challenges the idea that economic progress should be measured exclusively through immediate financial returns, industrial output or infrastructure development. It demands that governments consider the consequences of their decisions beyond their own political terms and electoral cycles.

Applied to the proposed Dangote East Africa Refinery in Lamu, this principle raises fundamental questions about the kind of development Kenya is pursuing and the legacy it intends to leave behind. What happens to the marine environment if industrial activities result in pollution? What happens to fishing communities if their access to traditional fishing grounds is disrupted?

INFOGRAPHIC/UN.

What happens to local residents if industrial development affects their land, water resources, health and livelihoods? What happens to the cultural and natural heritage that makes Lamu internationally significant? And, perhaps most importantly, what happens to future generations if the environmental consequences of today’s decisions become irreversible?

These are questions that cannot be dismissed as political hostility, economic sabotage or attempts to extort an investor. They are legitimate concerns arising directly from the fundamental principles of sustainable development. Indeed, the Brundtland Report requires governments to look beyond immediate economic benefits and consider whether development choices preserve the natural and social foundations upon which future prosperity depends.

The United Nations 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, adopted by world leaders in September 2015, reinforces this position. The Agenda establishes 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), supported by 169 targets, and expressly recognises that sustainable development has three interconnected and indivisible dimensions: economic development, social inclusion and environmental protection. These dimensions must be pursued in a balanced and integrated manner. It is therefore misleading to present economic growth as an objective that automatically takes precedence over environmental protection and social welfare.

Goal 7, which promotes access to affordable, reliable, sustainable and modern energy, must be considered alongside Goal 13 on climate action, Goal 14 on the conservation and sustainable use of oceans and marine resources, and Goal 15 on the protection of terrestrial ecosystems and biodiversity.

Equally important are Goal 3, which concerns good health and well-being, Goal 8 on decent work and sustainable economic growth, Goal 9 on sustainable industrialisation, and Goal 16, which calls for effective, accountable and inclusive institutions.

The significance of these goals lies in their interconnectedness. Kenya cannot claim to be advancing sustainable industrialisation while ignoring the possible implications of an industrial project for marine ecosystems, public health, local livelihoods and climate commitments. Neither can the promise of employment automatically justify development arrangements that might leave affected communities bearing disproportionate environmental and social costs.

Mr President, the proposed refinery must therefore be examined against the full range of these commitments. The government must demonstrate how the project will contribute to sustainable industrial development while protecting the environment, respecting the rights of local communities and supporting Kenya’s broader climate and biodiversity objectives. It must also explain how the project fits into the country’s long-term transition towards a more sustainable energy system. These are particularly important considerations for an investment of the scale and potential environmental significance associated with a major petroleum refinery.

There is also the question of intergenerational equity, one of the most important principles underpinning sustainable development. This principle recognises that the present generation does not own the environment in an absolute sense. Rather, it has a responsibility to manage natural resources in a manner that preserves opportunities and environmental quality for those who will come after it. The people of Lamu today have a legitimate interest in employment, investment and improved infrastructure. Their children and grandchildren have an equally legitimate interest in clean water, healthy marine ecosystems, productive fishing grounds, protected cultural heritage and a safe environment.

It would therefore be fundamentally wrong for the government to assess the proposed refinery solely through the immediate economic opportunities it promises without establishing what its environmental and social costs might be over the coming decades. Sustainable development requires long-term thinking, not decisions driven by the excitement surrounding an investment announcement or the political prestige associated with attracting a wealthy international investor.

The precautionary approach is equally relevant. Where there are reasonable grounds for concern that a proposed activity could cause serious or irreversible environmental damage, uncertainty should not become an excuse for postponing appropriate preventive measures. This does not mean that every industrial project must be rejected because environmental risks exist.

Rather, it means that those risks must be identified, investigated, understood and addressed before decisions that could have lasting consequences are made. For a project of this magnitude, the government and the investor should demonstrate that environmental risks have been adequately assessed and that credible measures exist to prevent, minimise and remedy potential damage.

Beyond these environmental and economic considerations, the United Nations has established principles of effective governance for sustainable development through its Committee of Experts on Public Administration (CEPA). These 11 principles were endorsed by ECOSOC in July 2018 to guide governments in building effective, accountable and inclusive institutions capable of implementing the 2030 Agenda. They are organised around three broad areas: effectiveness, accountability and inclusiveness.

The first category, effectiveness, comprises competence, sound policymaking and collaboration. Competence requires public institutions to possess the expertise, resources and capacity necessary to discharge their responsibilities effectively.

In the context of the Lamu refinery, this means that government agencies responsible for environmental regulation, land administration, public health, energy and industrial development must demonstrate that they have the technical and institutional capacity to assess a project of this complexity. It is not enough to announce an investment and celebrate its anticipated economic contribution. The institutions responsible for protecting the public interest must be capable of independently evaluating its implications.

Sound policymaking requires decisions to be based on credible evidence, proper analysis, strategic planning and an understanding of foreseeable risks. It also demands coherence between government policies. Kenya cannot pursue industrial expansion without adequately considering its environmental obligations, climate policies, land-use planning and commitments to sustainable development.

The government must demonstrate that the proposed refinery has been subjected to a comprehensive assessment of its economic, environmental and social implications rather than being treated as an investment opportunity whose benefits are assumed and whose risks are left for communities and future generations to manage.

President William Ruto and Dangote Group President Aliko Dangote. PHOTO/PSCU.

The third principle, collaboration, recognises that governments cannot successfully address complex development challenges in isolation. They must work with other levels of government, affected communities, civil society, professional organisations, researchers, investors and other relevant stakeholders.

In Lamu, this means that the national government must engage meaningfully with county authorities, local residents, fishing communities, environmental organisations and other stakeholders whose interests could be affected by the project. Consultation should not be reduced to a ceremonial exercise conducted after the most consequential decisions have already been made.

The second category of the UN governance principles concerns accountability. It comprises integrity, transparency and independent oversight. These principles are particularly important where public resources, private investment, land arrangements and potentially significant environmental consequences intersect.

Integrity requires public officials and institutions to act in the public interest, uphold ethical standards and resist corruption or improper influence. Transparency requires government decisions, relevant agreements, approvals and supporting information to be accessible to the public. Independent oversight ensures that decisions and actions can be scrutinised by institutions that are sufficiently independent to assess compliance and hold those responsible accountable.

Mr President, these principles bring us back to the fundamental questions surrounding the proposed Lamu refinery. Why should Kenyans be made to feel that demanding access to relevant project documents is an act of hostility towards investment? Why should citizens asking about ownership structures, contractual commitments, land arrangements and environmental approvals be portrayed as people standing in the way of national development? Transparency is not an obstacle to economic growth. It is an essential condition for responsible investment and public confidence.

A government that is confident that it has followed the law should have no difficulty explaining its decisions and making relevant information available in accordance with applicable legal requirements. Indeed, transparency protects both the public and the investor by reducing uncertainty, strengthening accountability and establishing the legitimacy of the project.

The third category concerns inclusiveness and contains five principles: leaving no one behind, non-discrimination, participation, subsidiarity and intergenerational equity. Together, these principles demand that development benefits and decision-making opportunities are not concentrated among politically influential individuals, powerful corporations or wealthy investors while vulnerable communities carry the greatest risks.

The principle of leaving no one behind is particularly relevant to Lamu. Development should improve the lives of ordinary people, including those whose livelihoods depend on fishing, tourism, small businesses, agriculture and other activities linked to the natural environment. These communities should not be treated as inconveniences that must be accommodated after major investment decisions have been made. They are among the principal stakeholders in the future of their county and must have a meaningful voice in determining its development priorities.

Non-discrimination requires that affected people receive fair treatment regardless of their economic circumstances, social position or political influence. Participation requires that citizens have genuine opportunities to influence decisions that affect their lives. Subsidiarity recognises that decisions should be taken as closely as possible to the people affected, at the most appropriate level of governance. Intergenerational equity, as already discussed, requires that today’s development choices do not undermine the opportunities and welfare of future generations.

These principles reinforce the importance of meaningful public participation, particularly in environmentally sensitive locations. They also demonstrate why dismissing legitimate public concerns is inconsistent with the spirit of sustainable development. The communities of Lamu cannot be expected to accept decisions about their land, environment and livelihoods without adequate information, consultation and consideration of their concerns.

The principles are also consistent with Principle 10 of the 1992 Rio Declaration on Environment and Development, which recognises three essential elements of environmental democracy: access to environmental information, public participation in decision-making and access to justice. These rights are fundamental to ensuring that citizens can contribute meaningfully to environmental decisions and seek appropriate remedies when their interests are threatened.

This is precisely why environmental assessments, public consultations, independent regulatory scrutiny and access to relevant project information are so important. They are not merely administrative formalities or procedural hurdles designed to delay investors. They are mechanisms through which governments establish whether development proposals are environmentally responsible, socially acceptable and economically justified.

Mr President, the point I am making is not that Kenya should abandon the proposed refinery or reject the benefits that responsible industrial investment could bring. Rather, Kenya must ensure that the project meets the standards of development that it has committed itself to pursuing internationally. There is no contradiction between attracting investment and respecting internationally recognised principles of sustainable development. On the contrary, responsible investors should welcome transparent institutions, predictable regulations, credible environmental assessments and meaningful community engagement.

The government must also recognise that sustainable development is not simply about the construction of factories, roads, ports and other physical infrastructure. It is about improving human welfare while maintaining the environmental systems that make economic and social progress possible. A refinery that creates employment but undermines local livelihoods, threatens sensitive ecosystems or leaves future generations with substantial environmental liabilities cannot automatically be described as sustainable development.

Kenya has an opportunity to demonstrate that it can attract major international investment without compromising its constitutional values, environmental responsibilities and international development commitments. That opportunity should not be squandered by treating legitimate questions as acts of economic sabotage. Nor should the pursuit of an ambitious industrial project be allowed to weaken the institutions and safeguards that are supposed to protect the public interest.

I therefore urge you, Mr President, to reconsider the manner in which criticism of the Lamu refinery is being characterised. Instead of questioning the motives of those demanding accountability, the government should address the substance of their concerns. Instead of portraying environmental scrutiny as opposition to economic progress, it should demonstrate how the project satisfies the standards of responsible and sustainable investment. Instead of treating public participation as an inconvenience, it should embrace it as an essential component of democratic governance.

The test of leadership is not how quickly a government can attract a billionaire investor or organise a high-profile groundbreaking ceremony. It is whether it can make difficult development decisions transparently, lawfully and responsibly, while protecting the interests of both present and future generations.

Ultimately, the proposed Dangote East Africa Refinery must be judged not merely by the amount of money invested, the number of barrels of crude oil processed or the employment opportunities promised. It must also be judged by whether it advances inclusive prosperity, protects Lamu’s ecological and cultural heritage, respects affected communities, strengthens accountable institutions and contributes to a genuinely sustainable future.

That is the standard established by the Brundtland Report. That is the ambition embodied in the United Nations 2030 Agenda. And that is the spirit of the principles of effective governance for sustainable development endorsed by ECOSOC.

Kenyans are therefore not asking for anything extraordinary when they demand that their government observes these principles. They are simply asking for development that respects people, protects the environment, upholds accountability and safeguards the future. Such demands should never be confused with extortion. They are legitimate expectations of responsible government and the very foundations upon which sustainable development must be built.

So when Kenyans ask to see the agreements, approvals, ownership structures, environmental documents, land arrangements and other records underpinning a Sh2.2 trillion project, they are not asking for a favour. They are asking to exercise a constitutional right. What exactly is the government asking Kenyans to trust? This is where transparency becomes unavoidable.

Members of the public at the ground-breaking ceremony. PHOTO/PSCU.

Kenyans want to know the contractual architecture behind the refinery. They want to know what Kenya has committed. They want to know what Dangote has committed. They want to know who ultimately owns and controls the Kenyan project company.

They also want to know what land has been allocated, on what terms and after what process. They want to know how affected residents will be compensated, what environmental safeguards have been approved and what obligations the investor has to local communities.

I also want to know what the Kenyan people receive in return for the land, infrastructure, public support and regulatory approvals being deployed around this project.

These questions have become even more urgent because the refinery groundbreaking occurred against the backdrop of a live land dispute. On September 25, 2026, the Malindi Environment and Land Court ordered the parties to maintain the status quo concerning disputed land associated with the project, following a case brought by 133 residents. The matter is scheduled for further hearing on October 14.

The court order did not stop the ceremonial groundbreaking. But its existence should have made everyone pause and ask a basic question: Why are we celebrating first and resolving the outstanding legal questions later?

There is another issue that I cannot ignore and which has already been raised by Linda Mwananchi leader and Nairobi Senator Edwin Sifuna. President Ruto took the constitutional Oath of Allegiance and the Oath of Due Execution of Office.

Under the Oath of Allegiance, the President swears or solemnly affirms that he will “obey, preserve, protect and defend” the Constitution and all other laws of the Republic.

Under the Oath of Due Execution of Office, he swears or solemnly affirms that he will serve the people and the Republic of Kenya and perform his functions in accordance with the Constitution and the laws of Kenya, “without fear, favour, affection or ill-will.”

Those oaths are prescribed in the Third Schedule pursuant to Article 141(3) of the Constitution. They are not ceremonial poetry. They are a constitutional commitment.

So when Kenyans ask whether the Lamu refinery process has complied with Kenyan law, they ate not attacking the President personally. They are asking him to live up to the very constitutional oath he took.

If the project has complied with every requirement, then publish the evidence and let the documents speak. There is an additional reason why this project demands extraordinary scrutiny.

President William Ruto and Dangote Group President Aliko Dangote walking towards the venue of the Dangote East Africa Refinery ground-breaking ceremony in Lamu. PHOTO/PSCU.

Lamu is environmentally and culturally sensitive. Lamu Old Town is a UNESCO World Heritage site, and the wider area has a distinctive ecological, cultural and social character. That makes questions about land, marine ecosystems, fishing, heritage, livelihoods and cumulative industrial impacts particularly serious.

This is why development in Lamu cannot be judged merely by the number of barrels the refinery will process or the number of jobs politicians promise. Development has to be sustainable. It has to respect communities. It has to respect the law. And it has to protect the rights of future generations.

Let me be clear: if somebody is demanding money from an investor in exchange for withdrawing a legitimate objection, that is a matter for the law. But a citizen filing a court case over land is not automatically an extortionist.

A journalist asking to see government contracts is not automatically an extortionist. A resident demanding compensation is not automatically an extortionist. An environmentalist demanding an assessment is not automatically an extortionist.

A senator demanding disclosure of public information is not automatically an extortionist. And a Kenyan asking whether the government followed the law is certainly not an extortionist.

Calling every critic a broker or extortionist does not answer the criticism. It merely changes the subject. The real issue remains: show us the paperwork.

Lawyer Dr Ekuru Aukot has called for disclosure of documents relating to the project, including the contract between the Government of Kenya and Dangote East Africa Refinery and Petrochemicals SEZ and information on the company’s beneficial ownership.

He has also sought details of the company’s directors, CR12 records for locally incorporated corporate shareholders, corresponding records for foreign corporate shareholders, constitutional documents of relevant corporate shareholders and information identifying the ultimate beneficial owners.

Those requests go to the heart of transparency. Who owns the company? Who controls it? Who sits on its board? What exactly has Kenya agreed to? What obligations have been assumed? What benefits have been secured for Kenyans? And what happens if the project fails to deliver what has been promised?

These are reasonable questions for a project of this scale. The refinery could potentially transform Kenya’s energy sector and Lamu’s economy.

The project is expected to create major employment opportunities, expand industrial capacity and strengthen regional energy security. The government has presented it as a flagship investment capable of transforming Kenya’s economic fortunes.

I do not dismiss those possibilities. But neither should we allow the promise of prosperity to become an excuse for procedural shortcuts. Kenya does not have to choose between investment and the rule of law. We can have both. Indeed, we must have both.

Ethiopia Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed speaking at the ground-breaking ceremony  of the Dangote East Africa Refinery in Lamu. PHOTO/PSCU.

A serious investor should welcome a transparent regulatory process because it gives the investment certainty and legitimacy. A serious government should welcome scrutiny because it demonstrates that its decisions can withstand examination. That is how sustainable investment works.

President Ruto has repeatedly presented the refinery as evidence that Kenya is open for serious investment. Then let Kenya demonstrate that it is also open to serious scrutiny.

Let NEMA publish the relevant environmental approvals. Let the government publish the agreements it is legally able to disclose. Let the public understand the land arrangements. Let affected communities understand their rights. Let the environmental and social safeguards be independently scrutinised. Let the courts determine the disputes before them.

And let Kenyans see the ownership and beneficial-control structure behind a project that will have consequences far beyond the ground-breaking ceremony.

That would silence far more critics than presidential denunciations ever could. Because transparency is not the enemy of investment. Transparency is what gives investment legitimacy.

The Dangote refinery may indeed become one of the most consequential industrial projects in Kenya’s history. But its legacy should not be that Kenya learned to bend its rules whenever the cheque was big enough.

Its legacy should be that Kenya proved something more important: that even the biggest investor must obey Kenyan law; that even the most powerful government must answer to the Constitution; and that even the poorest citizen has the right to ask questions about a project that may change the future of his or her community.

That is not extortion. That is citizenship. That is accountability. And that is what constitutional democracy looks like. The refinery can have billions. The President can have power. Dangote can have global influence.

But none of them is above the law.

The writer is an award-winning environmental and investigative journalist.
Radio Africa Eco News
Africa Eco News TV
Photo Gallery
Category

Be among the first ones to know, Signup for our Newsletter